The recent changes following the National Association of Realtors (NAR) lawsuit have sparked widespread discussion and, unfortunately, a fair share of misinformation. With the new rules officially rolled out, it’s essential to separate fact from fiction. Here are the top four myths currently circulating about these changes and the truth behind them.
Myth 1: Sellers Are No Longer Offering Buyer Agent Compensation
This is one of the most common misconceptions. The truth is that sellers were never required to offer buyer agent compensation, and this hasn’t changed. Sellers may still choose to offer this compensation for various reasons, but it will no longer be marketed on the Multiple Listing Service (MLS). Instead, this information can be shared through other means such as flyers or personal websites. Additionally, buyer agents now need to negotiate their compensation within the offer, which will be explicitly stated in writing. This new requirement emphasizes transparency in real estate transactions, but it doesn’t mean that buyer agent compensation is disappearing.
Myth 2: Home Prices Will Drop Because Buyer Agent Compensation Inflated Them
This myth is particularly misleading and has been perpetuated by some reputable sources. The idea that home prices will decline because of changes in buyer agent compensation is unfounded. Sellers typically aim to get the most value for their homes, and the notion that they would reduce their asking price due to changes in agent compensation is not reflective of reality.
The real factors that have historically inflated home prices include extremely low-interest rates and a significant imbalance between supply and demand. When interest rates were at historic lows, buyers often bid well above the asking price, which set new benchmarks for home values. Additionally, a lack of adequate housing supply to meet growing demand has been a major driver of price increases—not buyer agent compensation.
Myth 3: These Changes Benefit Home Buyers
Some believe that the changes stemming from the NAR lawsuit are a win for home buyers. However, this isn’t entirely accurate. While buyers will now sign a contract with their agents outlining compensation, this could potentially increase costs for them. If the buyer’s agency agreement specifies a certain percentage for the agent’s fee, and the seller offers less than this amount, the buyer may have to cover the difference. This adds another financial hurdle for buyers, on top of other expenses like closing costs, down payments, and inspection fees.
On the positive side, having a signed agreement with a buyer’s agent ensures that the agent has a fiduciary responsibility to the buyer, which is a significant benefit. However, from a financial perspective, the changes are more likely to add costs than reduce them.
Myth 4: Sellers Offering Buyer Agent Compensation Are Paying to Be Negotiated Against
This myth suggests that sellers are at a disadvantage when they offer buyer agent compensation because they are essentially paying for someone to negotiate against them. While this perspective is understandable, it overlooks the benefits of having strong representation on both sides of a transaction. A good buyer’s agent helps to keep deals together, which ultimately benefits sellers by reducing the risk of a sale falling through. Failed sales can cost sellers both time and money, particularly in competitive markets where time on the market is critical.
Moreover, buyer agents can help structure offers in ways that are beneficial to both parties, ensuring that the sale proceeds smoothly. In multiple offer situations, a skilled buyer’s agent is crucial in crafting an offer that appeals to the seller, helping to secure the best possible outcome for all involved.
Bottom Line
The changes resulting from the NAR lawsuit have undoubtedly altered some aspects of the real estate transaction process. However, it’s important to dispel the myths that have emerged. Sellers can still offer buyer agent compensation, home prices are not likely to decrease due to these changes, and while buyers may face additional costs, the overall structure of the real estate market remains robust. Understanding these nuances is key to navigating the new landscape successfully.
To learn more, watch our latest Monday Market Update: